Some say everything is bigger in Texas: steaks, dreams, and deep pockets. In a rare move, the Texas Senate pledged $1 billion for a school vouchers program and proposed legislation to grant children who enroll in private schools $10,000 in scholarships to help pay for their education.
Senate Bill 2 (SB2), authored by State Sen. Brandon Creighton (R), would deliver for Gov. Greg Abbott the comprehensive "school choice" program that he has been requesting since the 2023 session. Proponents call the program an education savings account (ESA), but Democrats and a few hold-out GOP folks worry it will deplete public school funding while prioritizing private institutions.
It's complicated.
Nuts and Bolts
According to a statement from Creighton's office, his plan puts students and parents first and foremost:
"School choice is a proven driver of success. Across the nation, it expands opportunities for students while resulting in meaningful improvements in public schools. Competition is not a threat to any one school but rather an opportunity to deliver better results for all Texas students. This legislation includes safeguards to ensure Texas avoids the challenges faced by other states while delivering a program tailored to the needs of our families."
If one listens to the proponents, it's a solid plan with freedom of choice. The program will cater to first-time students, from eligible preschoolers to kindergarteners, and those currently enrolled in public schools.
Homeschoolers and those who attend private institutions can pocket $2,000 annually for supplies and other necessary learning materials. Parents who would enroll their child in a private institution can claim up to $10,000 per child to cover the cost - unless the student has disabilities, which notches that figure up to $11,500.
Texas Parents Are All In on Vouchers
A recently published survey from the Hobby School of Public Affairs at the University of Houston and the Barbara Jordan-Mickey Leland School of Public Affairs at Texas Southern University revealed a significant majority of Texans demanded school choice initiatives. It was a juicy carrot to add in vouchers and give parents more control over the needs of their children. The plan also tends to allow low-income families access to different institutions. The survey reported, "This trend highlights a growing interest in alternatives to traditional government schooling, reflecting broader national debates about educational reform and parental choice."
A thorough analysis of SB2 reveals how the funds would be distributed: 80% of allocated ESAs are earmarked for low-income households or students with disabilities currently enrolled in public schools, with the remaining 20% distributed via lottery for other applicants with no income ceiling.
Parents embrace SB2 for a plethora of beneficial reasons, but lawmakers are not all reading from the same textbook.
Whoa, Nellie!
In 2023, Texas earmarked $4 billion in new money for public schools, but lawmakers couldn't agree on allocating the funds, which sat unused as politicians bickered. The whole mess deeply divided the state GOP, and several rural Republicans crossed the line and voted with Democrats to kill the voucher part of the proposal. Will SB2 suffer the same fate? Democratic lawmakers hope so.
"Vouchers are a scam. They look great on the face of it, but as you peel off the layers, it's going to be so bad for our state," State Rep. Salman Bhojani (D) told reporters.
Abbott believes this year is different and declares he has the votes. But State Rep. Gary VanDeaver (R) didn't warm to the idea over the last 24 months. He went so far as to use his defection in a political ad, saying, "Last year, I stopped a bill that would have handed out school vouchers, your tax dollars, to illegal immigrants. Border security is about more than just walls. It's also about the incentive which encourages illegal crossings in the first place."
Creighton is leery of the House passing the bill, saying, "When you offer historic money and historic flexibility, and that is rejected, you find yourself somewhat confused on what would be acceptable, and I'm not sure this session that we can come back again with the unprecedented framework, dollar for dollar, that we offered last session."
So, is SB2 the golden ticket for Lone Star State students? Well, it's complicated.
.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
