web analytics

SCOTUS Abortion Showdown Is Official

The Supreme Court set to hear arguments for the potential landmark abortion case of Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health.

The Supreme Court has announced that it will hear arguments on Dec. 1 challenging Mississippi’s Gestational Age Act, which prohibits almost all abortions after the 15th week of pregnancy. Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization (Dobbs is the name of Mississippi’s State Health Officer) is the case challenging the law whose enforcement is stayed during the court battle. The appeal was accepted by the Supreme Court in May to settle the question of whether abortion restrictions performed on pre-viable fetuses are constitutional.

Texas Two-Step

New banner Legal Affairs with ScottDon’t be fooled by the Supreme Court’s recent refusal to strike down the Texas abortion law that recently went into effect. The Texas case (Whole Woman’s Health v. Jackson) concerned only whether the Supreme Court would grant an injunction without a trial to stop that law’s implementation, not a considered analysis holding the law permissible under the Constitution. Moreover, the current state of the law on abortion is pretty clear regarding pre-viability restrictions: They are not allowed.

Two landmark Supreme Court cases establish this — Roe v. Wade from 1973 and Planned Parenthood v. Casey from 1992. Roe set the legal precedent that abortion is a right guaranteed by the Constitution. Casey, meanwhile, established the two new major tenets of abortion law. First, any law placing an “undue burden” on abortion services is unconstitutional. Also, once a fetus can survive outside its mother’s womb, abortion can be regulated and possibly prohibited, except for concern for the mother’s life. The Supreme Court has not altered these precedents, but now that could change.

Viability Has Got to Go

Mississippi’s argument is that the viability standard in Casey must be abandoned. The viability standard was introduced in Roe, but the then more primitive means of understanding fetal development used the trimester system. States could not regulate first-trimester abortions much and could prohibit third-trimester abortions altogether. Second-trimester pregnancies held a middle ground, with more regulations allowed. Casey recognized that improved technology detached Roe’s trimester analysis from the science, so it established viability as a standard regardless of gestational age.

Mississippi’s brief argued:

“To begin, medical advances make viability itself a moving target. What Mississippi could not prohibit in 1973, it can prohibit today. And what Mississippi cannot regulate today, it will be able to regulate in the future. Given the many medical advances our scientific community is constantly achieving, it is only a matter of time before development of an artificial womb moves ‘viability’ all the way back to the moment of conception.”

Because the abortion law precedent currently prohibits implementation of the Gestational Age Act, Court-watchers presume justices took the case to make a change in the law. Why take a case to affirm a lower court’s ruling? Especially one challenging a landmark precedent. The most compelling reason would be to revisit a precedent with a mind toward changing it. The Supreme Court agreed to hear this case to answer the following question: Are all pre-viability prohibitions on elective abortions unconstitutional?

~

Read more from Scott D. Cosenza. 

~

Liberty Nation does not endorse candidates, campaigns, or legislation, and this presentation is no endorsement.

Read More From

Scott D. Cosenza, Esq.

Legal Affairs Editor

Latest Posts

The Trump Polling Paradox

When the cameras caught sight of President Donald Trump at Super Bowl LIX, a roar of approval erupted as his...

Government Shutdown to Save the Government?

In the throes of all-out panic over the Department of Government Efficiency’s cavity searches of federal agencies...

Political Sin and Escape Velocity

The bigger the problem, the more complex the solution. Or is it? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_qH5P03sfY...

A Hard Lesson for the Globalist Agenda

A nation puts the interests of its own citizens first. That’s the purpose of having a sovereign government. But...

The Trump Revolution: DC Will Never Be the Same

Mind-blowing. No expression seems more appropriate for the totality of actions taken by President Donald J. Trump...

Keeping Pace! – Full Episode – C5 TV

The panel discusses what to do with USAID, the exhaustion of a new administration on the fourth estate, and why...

The Defense Department Can’t Dodge DOGE

President Donald Trump is turning the attention of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) to the...