Commemorated with flowers, brunch, greeting cards, and shiny baubles, one event struggled throughout the ages to become an official holiday, now celebrated on the second Sunday in May: Mother’s Day. Its evolution was a long and quirky process, starting with ancient Greeks hosting lavish festivals in honor of mother goddesses Rhea and Cybele. The history of celebrating mothers has taken a convoluted path, with humans, gods, and creatures that would take a master of mythology to unravel.
The American incarnation of Mother’s Day sprang, at the outset, from a protest of the Civil War. Enter Ann Marie Reeves Jarvis, a devout Methodist who defied both the Blue and the Gray by rendering aid and support to soldiers and their families – independent of either cause – through her Mothers’ Day Work Clubs. The clubs, originally formed with local churchwomen to teach child-rearing to new mothers, were effectively dispatched into the war, acting as de facto cooks, cleaners, doctors, and nurses. Jarvis was, at the very least, a strong-willed woman and she demanded peace from the communities in which the clubs performed their services. Her independent mandates were ultimately met with nary a complaint from the Union or Confederacy.
Feeling victorious in the summer of 1865, Jarvis organized a Mothers’ Friendship Day at the courthouse in Pruntytown, PA, to bring together soldiers and neighbors of all political beliefs. The event surpassed expectations, and despite the fear that it would erupt in violence, it was a resounding success. No bloodshed. No tears. No drama, and eventually it became an annual event in Pennsylvania.
Julia Ward Howe, the anti-war activist who penned the Battle Hymn of the Republic, began promoting Mother’s Peace Day in 1872. As with Jarvis, the goal was global unity after the horrors of the home-grown war, and the movement asked that people gather, pray, and listen to lectures in churches or social halls. But what began as a celebration to promoting global peace in the late 1800s made a hairpin turn upon the death of Ann Marie Jarvis in 1905.
Ruined by Commercialism?
Daughter of Ann Marie Jarvis, Anna Jarvis, took up the weighty community service mantle stitched by her mother and vowed to make her own incarnation of Mother’s Day a national holiday. In May of 1908, her first Mother’s Day was financially backed by a Pennsylvania department store owner. Billed as a day to honor the sacrifices a mother makes for her children, it was a resounding success that drew thousands of celebrants. Buoyed from success, Jarvis went for the all important calendar addition and began a letter writing campaign that involved every state. Persistence paid off, and President Woodrow Wilson deemed it an official national holiday – the second Sunday of each May – in 1914. And then Anna Jarvis spent the rest of her life, her savings, and finally her sanity in trying to remove Mother’s Day from the calendar.
As is the American way, the greeting card suppliers, florists, and other merchants seized on an opportunity to make a buck. And Jarvis’ holiday became, in her eyes, a spectacle. In the 1920s she lashed out, threatening to end the day entirely:
“To have Mother’s Day the burdensome, wasteful, expensive gift day that Christmas and other special days have become, is not our pleasure. If the American people are not willing to protect Mother’s Day from the hordes of money schemers that would overwhelm it with their schemes, then we shall cease having a Mother’s Day—and we know how.”
But that ship had already set sail towards a large profit margin, and all sorts of tagalongs began coming out of the woodwork to capitalize on the latest calendared holiday. A male interloper irritated Jarvis further by claiming he founded Mother’s Day through the Fraternal Order of Eagles, long before Jarvis. In 1904, Frank Hering, a faculty member of Notre Dame University, urged his fellow FOE members in “setting aside of one day in the year as a nationwide memorial to the memory of Mothers and motherhood.” Nothing came of his request but the organization today still gives credit to Hering and his pals as “true founders of Mother’s Day.” Jarvis’ response was simply a question to the nation: “Kidnapping Mother’s Day: Will You Be an Accomplice? Do me the justice of refraining from furthering the selfish interests of this claimant.”
It was rumored that Jarvis only lived to be recognized for the holiday by always scribing “Founder of Mother’s Day” after her signature. To say she was obsessed may be an understatement. And sadly, Jarvis died penniless in a mental sanitarium still angry at the commercialization of her holiday.
Mother’s Day American Style
Mother’s Day is a $25 billion one-day industry. About 122 million phone calls are made. On average, nearly $200 is forked over by each child to celebrate his or her mom. But let’s face it: Commercialization of this holiday has made sure we all take a moment to ponder the sacrifices our own mothers have made and encourage all people to make that phone call, or spend some long-overdue time with the women who brought us into the world.
And know this: You are the lucky ones. Liberty Nation’s own Editor-in-Chief, Leesa K. Donner, reminded us last year how fortunate it is to have one’s mother to lavish with flowers and accolades:
“She was different from anyone else I have ever known – a template of her own, if you will. Watching her pass was heartbreaking but being without her for over a decade is even more of a trial. Her words, her laugh, her love are buried deep within my soul, and for that, I will forever be grateful.”
I am one of the fortunate ones: My mother, Lucy, is a saucy, independent lady who still influences almost every decision I make. She is a blessing every day in every way.
Liberty Nation encourages you, if you can, to call your mom, take her to church, and then spend some time at her favorite restaurant imbibing, reminiscing, and celebrating the bond between a mother and child. No matter how much you love her, she will always love you more. Commercialization aside, Anna Jarvis would be proud.
At Liberty Nation, we love to hear from our readers. Comment and join the conversation!